Entertainment /
TIFF 2015 Interview: Guilty Director Meghna Gulzar
_79a.jpg)
ANOKHI goes in-depth with the woman behind the riveting portrait of the 2008 Noida double-murder case.
Whenever a South Asian superstar like Irrfan Khan comes to TIFF, his presence alone attracts a fair share of attention from the international media. But the film he arrived with this year, Guilty (Talvar), built up plenty of buzz on its own, for the mere fact that it’s a dramatization of the now-infamous 2008 Noida double-murder case, in which two married physicians — Rajesh and Nupur Talwar — were convicted of killing their teenaged daughter. Despite the conviction, the case remains shrouded in mystery and controversy — which led director Meghna Gulzar to sign on for this uniquely engaging account, which weaves together three separate theories of what actually happened to young Aarushi that night. At TIFF, we spoke to Gulzar about turning this real-life mystery into a crime drama, and the challenge of crafting a neutral account of such a divisive, highly publicized case.
Photo Credit: TIFF
Matt Currie: What made you want to dramatize this already highly publicized case?
Meghna Gulzar: I think it’s a story that needs to be told. The coverage has been spread over such a long time, that a lot of information is fragmented. Putting it all together and consolidating it into a complete picture was very important because, in spite of everything being over and done with and the trial and the verdict, there is a lack of closure, still a lot of unanswered questions. And I think [my motivation] was to explore these unanswered questions — not even dare to answer them.
Photo Credit: TIFF
MC: In your research, did you end up forming an opinion on exactly what happened in this case?
MG: The thing is, if one could make that opinion, it would mean that the people who were handling the case also knew what happened, and there would be clarity. What we discovered in the course of our research was that there were differing stories and they never, ever met at a common point. And still don’t. So therefore you can’t form an opinion, really.
MC: Is it difficult to maintain that sense of ambiguity, and not colour the viewer’s perception in one direction or the other?
MG: I would use the word neutrality — because there’s no point in making an investigative thriller if it’s going to be ambiguous. What we decided to do was portray each investigation and its theory with utmost equality and fairness. Like Vishal [Bharadwaj, the film’s screenwriter] said in a press conference, [our film has] similarities with Rashomon . . . there were differing points of view on the same incident, and so organically it lent itself to the script being written like that. And so what we tried to do was portray all versions with as much neutrality and objectivity, stringing all the facts together . . . and present it to the audience and leave them at a point where then they have to make their own decision.
Photo Credit: TIFF
MC: What was the most challenging part of making this film?
MG: We wanted to be completely neutral and represent all sides with equal fairness. Sometimes you are shooting sequences which tend to kind of sway you, either emotionally or psychologically; it was almost as if I had cocooned myself away from the fact that this is a true story, that these people are actually alive, that this really happened. For me this was a story, this was my screenplay, these were my characters and this was how I was supposed to break down the shots and execute the production; from time to time, it would come rolling back to me that this was real; and then you process it and you learn to deal with it.
Photo Credit: TIFF
MC: Irrfan Khan is obviously a living legend in the Indian film industry. How did he come on board as your lead CID investigator?
MG: We were all completely unanimous that there was only one person who can play the part of the investigator. We gave him the script, and then he asked for a meeting [at which] we were having a conversation about the film, about the case, about how I want to go about it, and the next thing we knew, he immediately agreed. Because he believed in the script, he believed in our integrity, our conviction in making the film. This part couldn’t have been played overzealously or overdramatically; we knew that Irrfan would deliver it in such an evolved way, which he has done. He takes underplaying and raises it to the level of an art form. And it was such a nuanced performance as an investigator with his own personal tragedy, and it’s quite a complicated role. Plus we shot with significant breaks in between [filming], but even then, holding onto the nerve of the character the way he did, he’s just brought Ashwin Kumar to life completely on this film.
Main Image Photo Credit: TIFF
Matthew Currie
Author
A long-standing entertainment journalist, Currie is a graduate of the Professional Writing program at Toronto’s York University. He has spent the past number of years working as a freelancer for ANOKHI and for diverse publications such as Sharp, TV Week, CAA’s Westworld and BC Business. Currie ...
COMMENTS
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
-
South Asian Horror Makes A Comeback: Films & Shows To Watch!
-
How Canadian Studio 'Cult Following Pictures' Is Changing Queer, Genre, & South Asian Storytelling
-
Pride In Frame: 10 Queer South Asian Stories To Watch This June
-
13 South Asian Music Maestros Who Revolutionized The Music Scene Forever
-
Exclusive Interview With Priyanka Bose & Raam Reddy On Magical Realism In 'The Fable'
-
From AI Ethics To Queer Love: IFFLA 2025 Honours Groundbreaking Winners
-
South Asian Cinema Takes Over L.A. – Check Out The Must-See Films At IFFLA 2025!
-
Stress Awareness Month: This Is What I Watch When I Am Tired Of Adulting (And It Works Every Time)
-
Sneaking Samosas In The Theatre To Watch 'A Nice Indian Boy' With Zarna Garg & Sunita Mani
-
Reimagining 'Mahabharata': An Exclusive Interview With The Visionaries Behind Toronto’s Theatrical Spectacle - Miriam Fernandes & Ravi Jain
-
Experience The Epic Mahabharata Like Never Before – Now On Stage in Toronto!
-
Exploring The Renaissance Of Female Characters In Bollywood, Hollywood & Beyond!
-
South Asian Stars Light Up Hollywood At Glamorous Pre-Oscar Celebration!
-
The South Asian Takeover: 2025’s Most Anticipated Hollywood Film & TV Releases
-
Bollywood 2025: The Ultimate Movie Lineup You Can’t Afford to Miss!
-
Mindy Kaling Becomes The Second South Asian Woman To Receive A Star On The Hollywood Walk Of Fame
-
8 Must-Watch Patriotic Films To Celebrate India's Republic Day
-
Up Close & Personal with Sandhya Suri on Her Oscar-Bound Film 'Santosh'
-
Bollywood 2024 Recap: The Good, the Bad, and the 'Who Asked for This?'
-
Must-Watch or Pass? Your Definitive Guide to the Upcoming Bollywood Films This Winter
-
How PBS Series 'Renegades' Celebrates American History's Most Badass Disabled Changemakers
-
14 Bollywood Remakes Vs. Their Hollywood Originals - Who Did It Better?
-
Catch Pakistan's 1st Ever Hand-Drawn Animated Film 'The Glassworker' & Other South Asian Films At Reel Asian Festival
-
World Mental Health Day: How Bollywood Has Used Its Power Of Storytelling To Address Mental Health Stigmas
-
Highlights Of Archie Panjabi, Neeru Bajwa & Iman Vellani At iSAFF2024
-
3x Emmy-Nominated Television Host & Producer Rasha Goel Launches New Podcast "Beyond the Glam" - Premiering Today!
-
Does Bollywood Accurately Portray Financial Struggles of India's Working Class?
-
Canada’s International South Asian Film Festival (iSAFF) Triumphantly Unveils Its Thrilling 2024 Lineup!
-
TIFF 2024: Our Chat With Writer-Director-Star Srinivas Krishna On The 4K Restoration Of His Hidden Canadian Classic ‘Masala’
-
TIFF 2024: First-Time Filmmaker Lakshmipriya Devi Dishes On ‘Boong,’ Her Funny & Profound Modern-Day Folk Tale Told From A Child's Point Of View
-
Nepotism Or Repetitive Content - What's Causing Bollywood's Slump Versus Punjabi & South Indian Cinema's Surge
-
Must-Watch Patriotic Films From India & Pakistan For Your Independence Day Celebrations
-
Villainous Vixens: How Bollywood's Leading Ladies Are Redefining Cinema's Most Memorable Antagonists
-
'Girls Will Be Girls' Wins Big At The 2024 Indian Film Festival Of Los Angeles (IFFLA)
-
OTT Revolution: How Streaming Platforms Are Transforming Indian Cinema
-
A Train Bloodbath With A 90% On Rotten Tomatoes - Why You Should Watch TIFF-Acclaimed Indian Action Flick 'Kill'
-
The Indian Film Festival of Los Angeles (IFFLA) Celebrates Its 22nd Edition June 27-30 With An Incredible Lineup Of 21 Films
-
Pride Month & Beyond: LGBTQIA+ Representation in South Asian Cinema
-
From Stoic Protectors to Emotional Anchors: A Father’s Day Tribute Through Hindi Cinema
-
Exploring South Asian Intergenerational Sacrifice With 'The Wrong Bashir', Now Playing In Toronto
-
Bollywood & Beyond: Must-Watch Films for Vibrant Insight Into Muslim Cultures
-
Over 50 Films From 9 Countries At The Eclectic South Asian Film Festival Montreal (May 24 - June 3)
-
Mother's Day Special: How Bollywood & Hollywood Super Moms Show Us Women Can Have It All!
-
Emerging Talents and Established Icons: Celebrate South Asian Heritage Month with Us!
-
Revealing Truths: South Asian Cinema's Contribution to Earth Day Awareness
-
Review: Monkey Man - Dev Patel Sets the Screen Ablaze with Electrifying Action
-
Exclusive Q&A With Diljit Dosanjh on the Dil-Luminati Tour and the Exciting Simplii Collaboration!
-
12 South Asian Female Artists Who Are Changing Hollywood's Landscape
-
Transitional Representation of South Asian Women in The World of Entertainment
-
Hot February 2024 Films From Bollywood And Beyond!
-
How Jesse "Punjabi Timbit" Singh Explores Emotional Healing Through His Comedy
-
Rukus Avenue Radio, The World's #1 South Asian Radio Station, Joins The iHeartRadio App
-
From Silent Frames To Global Fame: Key Moments That Shaped Bollywood
-
Hot January 2024 Films From Bollywood And Beyond!
-
Kerala Actor Santhy Balachandran Celebrates Her Three Incredible Releases In 2023
-
Hot December 2023 Films From Bollywood And Beyond!
-
The Real Reason Why Bollywood Directors Love English In Their Titles
-
Diwali Dance Fest Makes History at Walt Disney World® Resort!
-
TIFF 2023: Deepa Mehta and Sirat Taneja Share Why 'I Am Sirat’ Is The Transgender Story To Be Told
-
The International South Asian Film Festival 2023 (iSAFF) Wraps With A Celebration Of Outstanding Global South Asian Pathbreakers